SongKong Jaikoz

SongKong and Jaikoz Music Tagger Community Forum

Totally wrong matching with Bandcamp Album

Totally wrong matching with Bandcamp Album.
I have the album “Twelve & A Half Country Greats”, which is on Bandcamp https://stinkmagnetic.bandcamp.com/album/twelve-a-half-country-greats
but Jaikoz matched to album " Bad Luck Man"
https://delaneydavidson.bandcamp.com/album/bad-luck-man-2

Supportfile sent

Okay I will look tommorrow.

Hi, so its is a compilation album,and it seems that discogs matched track 3 to this

https://www.discogs.com/release/29636365-The-Grand-Chancellors-The-Grand-Chancellors?redirected=true

because you had Only allow match if all songs in grouping match to one album unchecked, which is unusual

And then the Bandcamp was checking the individual artists on the compilation, and because of track 6 by Deleaney Davidson it seems to have allowed match of whole album to Bad Luck man album. Bandcamp tool doesnt work very well with compilations but with my testing that results with no match rather than an incorrect match.

So then I purchased album myself and ran Jaikoz against it and for me it is not matching to an album, so whats the difference ?

Perhaps you could redownload with the orignal metadata and see what happens for you, or if you cannot do this perhaps you could run a SongKong Status report so I can at least what is exactly in the songs now.

Only allow if all songs on album are matched
or
Only allow match if all songs in grouping match to one album
both were not set !!!
I tried again to match with bandcamp and now no album on bandcamp was matched (support file sent, but in this support file update bandcamp was used)
Again tested with autocorrect Bandcamp and again no album was matched.
(a second support file was sent)

Its fine for Only allow if all songs on album are matched to be unchecked, that is usual as it allows you to match to an album if you have songs missing, i.e you only have 10 of an 11 song album .

Okay so that is the behaviour I’m seeing so that doesn’t really help, even when I unchecked Only allow match if all songs in grouping match to one album it still didn’t match for me. What I was interested in was if the metadata in your Bandcamp files was different to the orginal download and if it was this that enabled the bad match.