[quote=bink]I’ve got it selected to only show the year, but I’m still getting the full date in a lot of entries.
[/quote]
This option is only used by Action/Local Correct/Correct Year, doesnt effect what is fixed from Musicbrainz. So you just need to run Correct Year
[quote=bink]
(I’ve also got the “earliest release” selected but I continue to get the year of whatever compilation or reissue it feels like–maybe my preferences just aren’t sticking for some reason.)[/quote]
A ‘release’ in Musicbrainz is a particular set of Songs, then there can be a release event for every Country that the release is released in, this is what Preferences/Musicbrainz/AutoFormat/When selecting country and year of release is for.
If an album is released with different/extra tracks then it is a new release but this particular option does not effect what release is selected.
So why aren’t you getting the earliest release, lets consider some of the reasons.
Maybe you don’t have the original release but a reissue with additional tracks. For example if you have 11 tracks, the original album only had 8 and then 3 were added to a reissue your tracks are going to get a better score on matching the reissue because the total no of tracks match.
Maybe your tracks came from a compilation album, and the compilation album is set in your album field, in this case its going to give a better score to the compilation album (everything else being equal. Delete the album field before matching to prevent it favouring a compilation.
Maybe your match is based on a Puid, and then Puid is currently only linked to the reissued track. You can help here by linking to the correct track and using Submit Musicbarinz/Puid Pairs to create a link to the original release.