Hello,
I have a strange result in the “Manual Correct Tags” window.
To explain this, i’ll take the following existing example:
- the track is “Inimical Chimera” from “After Forever”
- the ID3 tags are:
- The artist: “After Forever”
- The album: “Ephemera”
- The title: “Inimical Chimera”
- The PUID (MusicIP Id): 9ca41756-bcb5-0eda-cc09-b6d489fe7194 (computed by Jaikoz)
- all other ID3 tags are empty
The research on MB about the PUID gives “Inimical Chimera” on 3 different versions of the album “Prison of Desire”, but none from the album “Ephemera”:
http://musicbrainz.org/show/puid/?puid=9ca41756-bcb5-0eda-cc09-b6d489fe7194
According to MB, the album “Ephemera” has a track called “Inimical Chimera” but with a different PUID:
http://musicbrainz.org/show/puid/?puid=e800aee0-a991-e843-c05b-1934618548ab
You can see in the attached picture that the MusicIP is checked for all rows, including the album “Ephemera” which doesn’t have the same PUID as my track.
Why MusicIp is checked for “Ephemera”?
I think the cell should be checked only if the same PUID is found. If so, it will be evident that my track has the wrong Album tag: my track is not the one from the album “Ephemera” but the one from “Prison of Desire”.
I think this is a bug or… am i missing something about the meaning of this column?
Thanks for your help,
Pascal