Yes, do it this evening
From discogs Performer missing
Thanks, looks like there are some inconsistencies there, I will look into it in more detail as soon as i can.
1 Like
Raised https://jthink.atlassian.net/browse/SONGKONG-2654 and https://jthink.atlassian.net/browse/JAIKOZ-1476 and looking at this again.
The main problem occurs because code assumes all tracks have a recording object, then if the recording object contains relations they are added to release relations, if it doesnt we process release relations. However if a track contains no tracks relations then it wont have a recording object and then our code doesn’t process release relations either.
This explains Jazz Sabbath Tracks 2,3,4,6 being empty now fixed
Electric Upright Bass missing from known instrument list so added to list
For the Eugene Groove Groove On! album
Electric Piano missing because instrument is actually Electric Piano [Fender Rhodes] so have now made change to allow if it matches instrument once square bracketed information removed.
Soprano Saxophone missing from known instrument list so added to list
Fixes have been made to both SongKong and Jaikoz
Great
Thank you, will wait for update
Hi Paul just upload support files.
Songkong 11.1 lite: in spreadsheet album Jazz Sabbath looks perfect
Euge Groove (On!) is very tricky. report 48
Tenor Saxophone – Euge Groove (tracks: 2, 4 to 11) ----------only in track 6 & 9
Soprano Saxophone – Euge Groove (tracks: 1, 3) -------- missing
Organ [B3] – Euge Groove (tracks: 1, 3) --------- missing
Piano – Tracy Carter (2) (tracks: 1) ---------- missing
Flute – Euge Groove (tracks: 2, 10) ------------ missing
Jacky Terrasson (53) report 46
Keyboards and vocals ------- missing
Jacky Terrasson (A Paris…) report 50
https://www.discogs.com/de/release/5195278-Jacky-Terrasson-A-Paris [r5195278]
Marimba – Stefon Harris (tracks: 14) ---- missing
Vocals – Minino Garay (tracks: 14) — missing
I hope you are still interested to improve, thanks for this
Hi, found the error. SongKong is only allowing one instrument credit per person, raised an issue for this https://jthink.atlassian.net/browse/SONGKONG-2659 and will get this fixed soon.
Jacky Terrasson (A Paris…) report 50
https://www.discogs.com/de/release/5195278-Jacky-Terrasson-A-Paris [r5195278]
Marimba – Stefon Harris (tracks: 14) ---- missing
Vocals – Minino Garay (tracks: 14) — missing
So Marimba is missing from instrument list have added that, I cannot see any vocal credit but vocal credits are treated a bit differently anyway.
This report hasnt come over, but I expect covered by errors listed above.
I’ve now released SongKong 11.1.1 with fix on Windows, Linux and Docker (not yet available for MacOS so not posted update on forum yet), so please download and retry.
Now released for all platforms
Hi Paul
you are very fast today 
thanks
I have rechecked all above albums. All fine until now.
Only found euphonium missing. Don’t worry.
I look forward for updated Jaikoz, I have about 600 albums to check and I think it’s easier in Jaikoz.
1 Like
Hi Paul, me again
just uploaded support files.
in report 75 is flugelhorn missing
in report 76 bass drums and sax are missing
plenty tasks were ok
In the meantime songkong pro
Flugelhorn added, not sure at moment why the other ones missing as they are already in list.
okay the role data coming from Discogs is not as structured as MusicBrainz and takes more parsing
select release_id,artist_name, role, tracks from discogs.release_artist where release_id=5280694;
release_id | artist_name | role | tracks
------------+----------------------+--------------------+-------------
5280694 | Jeremy Monteiro Trio | |
5280694 | Paulinho Garcia | Acoustic Guitar | 8
5280694 | Jeremy Monteiro | Arranged By |
5280694 | Eric Schneider (3) | Clarinet | 5
5280694 | Jeremy Monteiro | Co-producer |
5280694 | Shawn Kelley | Co-producer |
5280694 | Winston MA | Cover |
5280694 | Paul Martin (46) | Double Bass | 2-5 & 7-13
5280694 | Tim Davis (13) | Drums | 2-5 & 7-13
5280694 | Chris Sabold | Engineer | 8
5280694 | Jared Klumper | Engineer |
5280694 | Jim Anderson | Engineer |
5280694 | Manny Sanchez | Engineer | 8
5280694 | Mathieu LeJeune | Engineer |
5280694 | Tracy Martinson | Engineer |
5280694 | Winston MA | Executive Producer |
5280694 | Greg Fishman | Flute | 8
5280694 | Greg Calbi | Mastered By |
5280694 | Jim Anderson | Mastered By |
5280694 | Jeremy Monteiro | Piano | 1-13
5280694 | Eric Schneider (3) | Soprano Saxophone | 3 & 11
5280694 | Eric Schneider (3) | Tenor Saxophone | 2 & 4
5280694 | Jacintha | Vocals | 1, 3, 6, 10
5280694 | Paulinho Garcia | Vocals | 8
The missing roles are the ones where tracks field uses the & character to seperate multiple tracks (and also ranges of tracks), we dont currently handle the & character, raised an issue for this
1 Like
Done although impossible to do for 100% take these examples, they are too hard to parse and the second one is a misspelling !
all except 7 & 14
all exept 5 & 6
1 Like
Great, thank you very much
I’ll keep on tagging until the next problem
don’t forget euphonium, post 32
Already added that one
1 Like
some more missing
https://www.discogs.com/de/release/1150177-Omara-Portuondo-Omara-Portuondo
Baritone Saxophone
Claves
Timbales
Guiro
Tres
https://www.discogs.com/de/release/4391644-Omara-Portuondo-Flor-De-Amor
Shaker
Pandeiro
Surdo
https://www.discogs.com/de/release/2677345-David-Sanborn-Closer
Bass Flute
one more
- Valve Trombone
Baritone Saxophone is here included 
Hi, okay added these.
And also relaxed the matching criteria to just need to match one word so now would match Baritone Saxophone, Tenor Saxophone or Any Saxophone because Saxophone is in the list.
1 Like