SongKong Jaikoz

SongKong and Jaikoz Music Tagger Community Forum

Classical Album's Artist/Album Artist order

Hi,

Would it be possible to have those Classical Album’s Artist and Album Artist ordered by:

Conductor, Artists, Orchestra?

I have several albums with the same conductor and orchestra that are placed far apart on my player because they have different order and thus treated as different Artists.

For example: Eiji Oue and Minnesota Orchestra are both:
Eiji Oue, Minnesota Orchestra
and
Minnesota Orchestra, Eiji Oue

Thanks

That is a good point you make, but currently Album Artist is taken as it is stored in the MusicBrainz/Disocgs database which usually accurately matches the Album Artist as displayed on the release.

The only adjustment SongKong makes is converting non-latin names to latin/English names if Format:Romanize non-latin scripts names where possible enabled and removing featured artists, if you have the Format:When Albums contain featured artists set accordingly

I think the key thing is not to set the Album Artist to particular order because sometimes the conductor is most prominent (e.g Simon Rattle), sometimes the artist most prominent (e.g Nigel kennedy), and sometimes orchestra etc. But if you have multiple albums by the same combination of artist(s) then you want to use the same order, I will raise an issue to consider this.

In the meantime yo can use Edit Songs to manually modify so it is consistent, I assume you dont have many albums where this is a problem ?

Raised - https://jthink.atlassian.net/browse/SONGKONG-1700

Hi Paul,

Thank you for creating the issue for me.
I understand that there are Albums which the artists, conductor, or orchestra is the main focus so the default should be as is.

I don?t have many albums with these issue.

Thank you