SongKong and Jaikoz Music Tagger Community Forum

Acoustid is not taken into account correctly

when matching single tracks with MB the acoustid is not taken into account correctly.
Example:

Track “b4b4bab8-300e-4cab-b543-1e58db36b8c1”

Linked MusicBrainz recordings

Title Artist Length Sources
Memories Are Made of This The Drifters 2:32 4
Memories Are Made of This The Drifters 2:29 9
Memories Are Made of This The Drifters 2:31 1
Spanish Lace The Drifters 2:30 1

Jaikoz searches in https://acoustid.org the acoustid, finds the list
Linked MusicBrainz recordings (see above)
Find 4 entries there and select the title with 1 source instead of the title with the highest number of sources, here 9 sources. In this case here Jaikoz chooses the wrong title.
I have noticed this behavior on several different tracks.
In Jaikoz version 10, the track with the highest number of sources is NOT selected.
So it comes again and again to wrong matches.

Here is another example:

Track “d030a02a-fe55-44c2-9a9c-26f9378705f7”

Linked MusicBrainz recordings

Title Artist Length Sources
How About You Bobby Darin 2:03 4
Lovin’ You Bobby Darin 2:14 13
Lovin’ You Bobby Darin 2:12 147
Lovin’ You Bobby Darin 2:13 6
Sittin’ Here Lovin’ You Bobby Darin 2:10 3

In this case Jaikoz matches to Bobby Darrin - Sittin’ Here Lovin’ You
And that is wrong!!!

Another one:

Track “8602e108-d4ed-42dc-8802-f0c9266fcebe”

Linked MusicBrainz recordings

Title Artist Length Sources
Having a Party Sam Cooke 2:22 13
Having a Party Sam Cooke 2:27 3
It’s My Party Lesley Gore 2:18 5
It’s My Party Lesley Gore 2:16 4
It’s My Party Lesley Gore 2:21 3
My Boyfriend’s Back The Angels 2:17 2
My Boyfriend’s Back The Angels 2:16 1
Party Lights Claudine Clark 2:23 191
Party Lights Claudine Clark - 3
Start the Party Again Lesley Gore 2:13 1

In this case Jaikoz uses Lesley Gore - It’s My Party instead of Claudine Clark - Party Lights!

With manual match I can see that Jaikoz gives Lesley Gore a score from 75 and Claudine Clark only 72. The acoustid sources of 191 should drive the score in Jaikoz so high that all other identification features should fade into the background.

Hi, you are correct.

At the moment we only filter out the recordings with the lowest no of sources but of the remaining matches we select match based on the release that has most matching songs rather than numOfSources, but this makes no sense when only have a single song rather than a group of songs, we should be incorporating numOfSources into the selection especially if one song has many more than the rest.

I have raised https://jthink.atlassian.net/browse/JAIKOZ-1248